Quote
Psychologically, it created a new phase of our relationship. People love to categorise and name things. It was like saying, 'So we've done the meeting and the building, our relationship is mature and secure, let's sign that off and carry on.' Which is nonsense, because we're always working on being better partners for each other, but it was nice to stop, take a rest, and reflect on how far we'd come.
See, that's interesting, because I can see it from both angles on this.
On the one hand, I have a certain appreciation for ritual. I can see the value in taking time to gather the people we love and say "Hey. I'm serious about this. For reals. Now eat cake."
On the other hand, the prevailing idea seems to be that marriage is the end goal of a relationship. But really, the marriage isn't the important part, and if you actually let yourself think that marriage is the "end" of anything, then you're probably going to fuck your marriage up pretty badly. Relationships need maintenance, as I'm sure you know.
I suppose, as with so many many things in life, the ritual can be great. The problem really arises when people start to focus more on the ritual than they do on the people.
*coughreligioncough*
Ahem.
Quote
Propriety is something I'm not a big fan of, along with etiquette, chivalry etc. But marriage, I feel, is changing in ways the older generation did not intend. For a start, the whole 'no sex before marriage' thing? My father-in-law said, sardonically, 'These days, it's no marriage before sex!' But actually, he's right. And good thing, too. Getting married before sex is naive and hugely risky. I'm a firm believer in no marriage before sex. I'm glad he hasn't gotten his way on that point. And, my wife didn't take my name, I took hers. The thing to bear in mind is that no matter how much the older generation tries to claim ownership and authority over things like marriage, the concept of marriage predates any of their cultural constructs. It predated Christianity. It predates pretty much everything. And it has always been changing.
It is funny how people who talk about "tradition" are often woefully ignorant of history. When they say "Traditional," what they mean is "the prevailing ideology when I was a young adult." Which isn't a very longstanding tradition.
Honestly, who cares what old people think? If they wanna get in here and make their case, let 'em. Otherwise, there's no point giving too much attention to their antiquated views. "No marriage before sex." is a pretty good way of putting things. I like that.
Said as if it's difficult to get me to ramble endlessly about literally any topic ever. =P
Quote
Yes, it is a scam. We got around a lot of that by finding a venue that was lovely and cheap (jackpot), who charged not much above cost. She also picked out her dress from a charity shop for £30.
Morrie has always said she'd like to get married in a Pizza Hut if we can manage it.
Quote
The dad giving away the bride is something that troubled me. Ultimately, I went along with it because it's what she wanted. I feel like I failed a little, because I think weddings should be updated to reflect the 21st century western values that we uphold. But I let Safron have her way because I felt it should be more her day than mine. that a wedding day is one of the few things aimed at women that men respect.
Arooooo.....
1. We're talking about your marriage and wedding now, which I'm not going to comment on. You seem very happy with it, and I'm happy for you. I do not denigrate anything you chose to do.
2. We're having a discussion, though, so I'm going to take the scenario you outlined, and talk about how I would handle it if it were Morrie and I. Which is what would be right for me, not what I think would be right for you.
Compromise is a big part of a relationship. So if I was getting married and the lady I was with wanted to be given away by her father, I'd tell her I wasn't a fan of that tradition, I'd tell her why I wasn't a fan of that tradition, and I'd be interested in having a discussion about it. But, like you, I think I'd concede immediately that if it's something she wanted, then it's something we would do.
But I certainly wouldn't merely turn the whole ceremony over to her. I mean, what we're talking about is a ritual celebrating a relationship, and symbolically making it a permanent bond. If the entire thing is orchestrated by only one half of the couple, then I feel like it's failed at being an effective ritual. The ritual should represent both of the people participating in it. It should be two visions coming together to create a singular event, the same way two minds are coming together to create a single life together.
BUT THAT'S JUST ME BEING ALL ARTSY FARTSY. Like I said, I have a thing for symbols.
Quote
Women are always 'proving' their equality by stating how much they like that one guy-ish film, or sometimes wearing guy-y clothes, or reminding us of that one woman who loves Call of Duty. Bringing women into all the things considered masculine. Essentially, bringing them towards us. That's not equality.
For sure it's not equality if it's an act. But if a woman actually likes those things, then it's just a shared interest.
If it's an act then that's weird, lying behavior. If Morrie someday told me she hates video games I'd be just as hurt as I would be if she cheated on me. That's fucked up.
Quote
When's the last time a guy went out in a dress purely in support of gender equality?
I mean, I know a lot of guys who wear dresses. And I suppose that in some ways they know they're making a statement. But mostly they do it because they like dresses.
Quote
Or tried to convince anyone they liked chick-flicks more than Star Wars or Lord of the Rings?
Does anybody like bad movies more than good movies?
Honestly, for most definitions of "chick-flick," it's really just synonymous with "bad movie." Which says a lot more about how the media views women than it does about the real state of gender equality on the ground. =P
Quote
Would I be right in saying that it's not weddings you disagree with, but the form they take? Is there a 'version' of a wedding and/or marriage that would better celebrate or express your vision of love?
I keep starting this, then deleting it and starting it over.
In the end, a marriage I could accept would be a marriage that doesn't look any different than the relationship that came before it. And a wedding I could accept would be a public affirmation of that relationship. One which focused on the individuals binding themselves together. No officiant or anything like that.